104 East 25th Street, New York, NY 10010  | 
(212) 254-4710  |  Mon - Fri, 10AM - 6PM
Follow Us:
  • We are happy to call you during the auction and place bids on your behalf. To arrange phone bidding, please call Swann's bid department during business hours.

    (212) 254-4710 ext. 0
    Mon - Fri 10AM - 6PM


    Or, e-mail a list of lots with the sale number and your contact information to phonebids@swanngalleries.com. Be sure to include a phone number where we can reach you.

    Bids may also be submitted via fax. Send a list of lots with the sale number and your contact information to (212) 979-1017. You will receive a confirmation before the sale.

    Sale 2394 | Lot 70
    Price Realized: $10,625With Buyer's Premium
    Show Hammer Price
    • Click Image To Enlarge

    • Sale 2394 Lot 70

      "NO COUNTRY IN THE WORLD NEEDS AN ARMY" GANDHI, MOHANDAS K. Letter Signed, "yours sincerely / MKGandhi," to Dr. John Haynes Holmes ("Dear Dr. Holmes"), in English, expressing surprise at the accusation of having stated that an independent India should form an army and navy commanded by an American general, and noting that Mr. Fey had visited and left this morning. 2 pages, small 4to, written on the recto and verso of a single sheet; lower edge trimmed (without affecting text), folds. Sevagram, 27 April 1940

      Estimate $5,000 - 7,500

      ". . . I have no recollection of my having told Dr. Sherwood Eddy that 'in the event that India does get its independence, it would proceed to form an army & navy' & that I would 'invite an American general' to command these forces, if only because for years I have held the opinion that no country in the world needs an army for its defence, much less India. I am engaged in making an experiment proving the truth of my proposition. It is therefore highly unlikely that I could have made the statement imputed to me. But I see you have not had anything direct from Dr. Eddy. You have only heard some such statement attributed to him. I would therefore advise you to have it confirmed by Dr. Eddy for I should be painfully surprised if I found that he had made it. . . ."
      In 1940, Holmes wrote to Gandhi concerning the claim--made by Sherwood Eddy in his book, I Have Seen God Do It (1940)--that Gandhi made statements to Eddy contradicting his expressed pacifism. In the July 28, 1940, issue of Harijan, Gandhi denied making any such statements and suggested that Eddy publish a correction.
      Rev. Dr. John Haynes Holmes (1879-1964) was an American clergyman, author, and activist who met Gandhi in London in 1931, thereafter supporting him and his causes.

      Price Realized (with Buyer's Premium) $10,625